| Varsity Away vs Bordentown | 22 May 2023 | Monday | Loss 4-0 |
| Varsity Home vs Bernards | 19 May 2023 | Friday | LOSS 3-1 |
| Varsity Away vs Warren Hills | 17 May 2023 | Wednesday | WIN 16-7 |
| Varsity Away vs Gill St. Bernards | 16 May 2023 | Tuesday | LOSS 7-3 |
| Varsity Home vs P'Burg | 12 May 2023 | Friday | LOSS 7-6 |
| Varsity Away vs Pope John | 10 May 2023 | Wednesday | LOSS 10-0 |
| Varsity/JV Away vs North Warren | 08 May 2023 | Monday | WIN 14-3 |
| Varsity Away vs Lenape Valley | 06 May 2023 | Saturday | WIN 10-1 |
| Varsity/JV Away vs Manville | 04 May 2023 | Thursday | WIN 15-2 |
| Varsity vs Wallkill Valley | 03 May 2023 | Wednesday | WIN 4-2 |
| Varsity/JV Away vs Bound Brook | 02 May 2023 | Tuesday | WIN 7-4 |
| Varsity Home vs South Hunterdon | 25 Apr 2023 | Tuesday | WIN 13-3 |
| Varsity Home vs Voorhees | 24 Apr 2023 | Monday | LOSS 4-3 |
| Varsity Home vs Warren Hills | 21 Apr 2023 | Friday | LOSS 5-0 |
| Varsity/JV Away vs Belvidere | 20 Apr 2023 | Thursday | WIN 15-3 |
| Varsity/JV Home vs Manville | 18 Apr 2023 | Tuesday | WIN 10-2 |
| Varsity Home vs Hackettstown | 14 Apr 2023 | Friday | LOSS 6-4 |
| Varsity Home vs Bound Brook | 13 Apr 2023 | Thursday | WIN 20-7 |
| Varsity Home vs Ramapo | 11 Apr 2023 | Tuesday | LOSS 11-4 |
| Varsity Away vs South Hunterdon | 05 Apr 2023 | Wednesday | LOSS 7-6 |
| Varsity/JV Home vs Belvidere | 04 Apr 2023 | Tuesday | WIN 12-0 |
| Varsity Away vs Hackettstown | 03 Apr 2023 | Monday | WIN 11 - 10 |
